Lessons from Litigation: Sometimes the System Works

by Jonathan A. Nelson

The recent Virginia Supreme Court decision in A&N Electric Cooperative v. Dietzel Enterprises, Inc. is at first blush a dry look at a safety statute in the commerce section of the Virginia Code which applies to few people in even fewer circumstances – this decision turns on whether a radio tower was a “communication circuit” as used in the statute, and therefore exempt from a requirement to indemnify the owner of a nearby power line.  However, despite the twists and turns of its procedural history, the outcome is encouraging in its message: though the legal system may have its difficulties, it can reach a just result for ordinary individuals.

The matter began in 2019 with a tragic electrocution of a construction worker where live power lines were not properly identified.  Without minimizing the work required to establish liability, the survivors received payment from the insurance companies while those companies could rely on a set of statutes and agreements to leave open the question of who was actually responsible for the payments.  Seven years and four courts later, the insurance companies are still working on a resolution between themselves, but the widow and the family aren’t part of the matter anymore. 

This kind of resolution isn’t automatic, but well-crafted statutes and smart attorneys who can keep the end goals in sight and resolve the parts of the case that don’t need to be dragged out keep the justice system just.

Virginia attorney Jonathan A. Nelson practices in estate planning, probate, trust administration, business formation, and estate and trust litigation, and brings nearly 20 years of experience resolving conflicts, negotiating settlements, vigorously advocating in the courtroom, and navigating compliance matters. He uses a personal touch and extensive legal knowledge to ensure that the particular needs and interests of each client are reflected in the legal services they receive.

The attorneys of Smith Pugh & Nelson, PLC, offer the experienced counsel, personal attention, and customized legal services needed to address the many complex issues surrounding estate planning, probate, and trust administration. Contact us at (703) 777-6084 to schedule a consultation.

html